Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout11012007 BSC Agenda Item 3 ! 3 z o w '..a p a w G c w 0 LL tQ ..,. .fir; t) O o j c **i C w ? w Fa m uo + to T z ro zy O -• o cM = -1 , ,-' 0 3 = -T sG ' o ro Q. - 3 . z �7 '±ri, tr o 0 0 m 2 w w W O € ?` i, O �« -*Pi c 0 rt LI o O to '4' to p a o z , m Q m Q o o m o w a p - � � " a ( - z C m = Q ', m c a o 7; 3 m yr o m "to = s -1 `D 'D 3 w 3 w ro -4 z n Q - 0 3 0 �c `a' C it C n 3 w to Q -+1 v .T.' C c <D Q 7 3 .' to -� T71-I es D 0 n T CD 3 3 0 C n O m ? O D O •w m .) W Q O 4 II', U) m a r A) N .44 M I p f 3 0 m N Y7 K m �. w v; ? s Q* C m n� o o- -" m m co fl 3 -8 c c o a .,t? s C CD ,. c7 m a m ° m CD 7 N w b ,Q O -< 6 w tt CD m C c_ t9 O i m G Z o Ali �° , cc ; 1 o s ° a H m ° m o m;. -i° N o g 0 m -)= co c ro o CD CD o 7? Q 0 . N o w 00 o m m F a o ° n k-< m m m m w 0 ran D a m c 7 �' D O gt) fi . o �. (D o m co C co D DJ �� w ° w 3' '5'. to 0 8- m ° � w 0 OQ CD 3 . ,-i m m N h m m m ° �_ 0 CD 40 C = iii ¢ N to R� //: , m o o .� o m 0 c 0 0 = a (n m a Z o ° w 6 C m ? 5- 7 0 a m CD m m cQ cn w m a m 0 o Z a m m o n o D 0 c D ti 0 CI) Z y > c6) Q t/ rn JJ M ' . (<D K m -0 r m o m �' o o m ° C mCD 0 3 m a o 5' m 77 m (D CD (D K 03 'z :• _ B. 0 o 3 0 0 " C 0 Cr) = r- ,-.4 (D o D < = r co ° O m w _, 0 CD .. 5 * m CD = D 0 5- (D e. F3 B a) N x `< ai w c = D 3 c m 0 C) co D m m m p' _ H CD D D D D a°i ° 3 c CD A N D 3 -I'0 L,-') o < m 3 so CD > m = o o ° ° N Q n ( H 3 3 - 53 = *' m CD M B CD a o w w aw m w Cn o (CT 3 (D 3 ° N m N ° m B. cQ o m m p O C U D CD 3 3 .= 2 a S(D N -0 0 ill (D O x.—N a 0 0 ° ° m -o =.m' CD Z . _ o ° 3 m 0 (0 m ° 0 0 = (D "! (D J co - a °- (fin C a CD N N -I _. a1 (D -P. 3 (D .. N-o CD N D K ' °- ° p A (D = (D = = a) ( . N ry � . < 0a 0 o 0 0 ' S N0 ° 3 O 5 N w c ° < G G 5 m a N W N CD°(r) C o ' C3 D -O 6 O (D = O .-. '° 3 3 O N 3 (3D CD 7J N Q oZ a 19 O ° `' CD CD N fD CD (D CD (D C CD < — 3 w B. 0 3 N 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 Q 3 N N W = 'D (o ,r ;••3 3 w a° O co 0 3 chi 3 = ° m m hCC � � 0 o CD CD D (D N (7 (3D 3 (D c 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 N O -O a B. N N (D CD (D CD CD CD CD (D a CD "< o ° B_- m -- 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 •-0 3 O N CD CD (D (D CD CD CD CD CD ° C N a CD B. ' B. ' ' B. B. B. B. N 3 c o m 3 (p N S c N . <• 3 a - 0 o 0< m w _ C -El. a Q fA - -D D D D = o °- ° (D a-(1) 0 3 - CD N CD N (D CD j '" (6D 7 W = O N (D < CD c (D Al N-Li j N tL] 3 (D 0- p 3 N ° 'fl O O CD C CD a N O< N O 0 Q j N N `'‹ N a N (D ch (D - a a < ,- 0_ 7 * N 3 N cn (D CD O W O 0 3 0 co . so NY C 3 O C - O a 0 CD a ° N = 3 Cn a O w . m w co = a -c1:2 0 0 v W o N 0 O -. N 3 CD O. 3 3 N C CD CD co O O = D a 7 3 O O 0 CU -' 0 0 6 7 (D CD 6 j N CD n ,•< a7 c < a a -I ° v 3' . a m CD a a 5 o 5 (D C,) = (0 5 a * = N (D a) N' CQ . 0 (D co O w r. CD (D = po ° a m 3 CD as 3 w m m B. 0 0, CD 3 (D a) ? N 0- r: N = a N O (p °- C N C. D CD - vi N N = X 0 = S a7 -° ] 3 CD CD 3 7 W a1 N (D N6 N O. O .0 c (° o <. a a (D O CD CS CD CD - N. N 6 O °�. E. 3 p - 3 °' n C_ Z.'o (D .-. a, C C ,-. O 3 N O a ° H '�.'O_ CD CD tT 21 3 CD ° CO 3 fD N P- 3 (D =-=• CD 3 (O O • _ o m m a 3 c 3- C CD N 3 v = 3 3 o_ m w CD o 5. 0 a = B. N (7) a a m a _a c o m. 3 a • D • or Z C m -< K m 0 O y m D TI Z 1 -1 2 71 (n 171 0 -I 6 w Z -I > 0 0 0 0 -I o C (D 5 Do s °. O v w w m 2 6 0 w CD ° S Q Z ° m cn El- Q o m 7 N X n �° 3 ' co CD N cD CD rn 0 CO cn co 5 m FA ,=. w (C/) a 0 a .n D 0 CD 0 CD m c _ ° _ ° 5 N w o 5 n 0 co E. 0 0 CD C to w a)cn ° w ? ° 0 37 o m `�° m Z °' c cD ° Cl) m ° ( = m -, -00 -°a 0 3 -. 0 D m o a m m m A) m a s o 0 6 a Q (o x 0- O. D m' ° ° ° 3 3 `� A) N o w `° CD cn N S Q o N ° 1� (n CD vC, O 3 CD ° `° ° ° O_ Q CQ -- CD s .. CD 0 w v o ° 0_ 0 a 3 ° m m a) m C cp0 m 0 `° 0 o ° 'i 3 ° g 5- ° 6 N -O' O- (Oa m 3 0' c°n 6 m S' 3 2. s w 3 3 c c m m ° ° g _ w °_ 0 n w 0 w N o ° m w 0 0 3 o L ° (D (D ? < C o O ° Q `<. -0 6 `< O 0 O O 3 - 0) a) w O 0 O- (0 N O a6) -y,,'. c 6 ° ° N 0 O (O (Q O' 0 CD CD CD CD n Q O_ 0 0- O< * O 9�'' Q O C C w 3 O ° < (A N w !n O 7 (D cQ CD u) O .» — (D 0 m m 5 3 0 3 0 o m 3 o ° u) a CD a -' p3, < Q ° a. c -c v 0 0 a) w 3 w ° o m m 3' o w 0 CD m Q � �. o w w cD 0 o w ° o ° n cr.) v c > < 0 n ° Q d ? 0 N C st 3 O 3 C 0- 0 0 O (D O CD - (D .-. A) .-. (D CD 0 6 w 0 O 0 w (D ° Q co ac) ^.' O (n -O °co O Q (n a, (°D N -. (On 6 0 m a C m S A) 0 O w 0 O N Ai 0 N o E. o ° 3 8 3 0 7 m m m w ° ° m K Qo O U) *. m a Q 6 o S m < o 9 ° - = vOi °' vi v°i 0 S ° w < N C CD c0 0 m 0 0 a w u = C)co cr 0 7 m ° L',' - F4 w Cr w ? c 0 3 0 ° 0- m o w Q 0 < n w cD m o c v° ac) .(c3 a (( � - a c. c a) o vw, o 0 w CI)) 0 2 0 (D 0 o 5 a) 0 > 3 0 a o CD w o a a o B .O. �1 -. a1 O< 'C O 0 CD CD CD 6 O O ° ° 0 -• - O '06 S 9 0- co j 0 3 a) w a) O CD CD O .O O O 6 ° O (D w w w Q O .�. CAD < -0 ° O CD O n D w m u° m 6 n o a (n Q 6 a c •3: ° c w °0 6 0 0 E. ) m o m o E' °_ w co 7 Q C CD N f O Q 5 °' 3 co -- -o -°O a) n �D NT w 3 w 3 m w cc) 3 C .< 0 , O w w Cr CD CD CD •`< CD 30 d y. (cn a) C_ O 00 'O co 5 co N 6 Q c ( (D .- I n 3 ° (D ° ° O O- ° 0 wp_ X c (o (n N N 3 N 1:C < Q CD C O O ° O w O< 0 -co (n (D w 5' CD Al w O (D 6 N 6 3 O (D N CD c o. a co D- a - v o - 0 ° a C' C Q a cc)CD 0 _ ° D w n -I o 0 CD CD cp 0 w a 0 Q w - CDD (D CD 3 (D ° CD Q ° < 0- 0 O 0 w (°/) CCD W N C) 0 0" N 4 (n ° C co w w .- 'o S CD (°p *. ° K 0 7 2 ° N C o 0 -0 0 '0 ° O a co 3 = ° a � o z.(0 w 7 a, 0 < (n 3 < O CD 0 (D C O CD cn a;a) -o O (D 0 0 CD ') 6 ° CD �, n Q 6 C O (D (_D,- <' -0 w 3 ... 6 ° w _ 0 S � C (� D ° x o c°j) O 3 N m n w 7 COD CD O o �. (0 o (D 0 0- CO 0 CD 'o y (D ° w o N 3 m 0 w 0 w 7 Q D to o = ^' ° w v O - w 0 y O (D C to 0 O 0 2_k4. w C. �_ co ° o w c' a o °o > w 0 = n m O 6 M a w a 00 0 w 0 O A) -° Q 3 O `< 0 fl- Q C -o o m - m 8 � w o w • Ck m o 3 Q 3 9 co' < co O ° Cr 0 < < "0 m 91 3 Q < ° w 6 u) a) 0 < < ° 0 w ° m -- w- 0 O N O u) riT CD ci O 0 < Q 3 a) (A -. o Q O ▪ o W N = X (p Q n -,F aa.. 3 3 n. O N N °co o• 0 (n O CD O CD c°j) a ° D O- C _ CD N ,.: wo ( • w c ° 0 O C 3 O * 0 Q 0- n 0 0 •° w w N O ° O< S CD °+ ' 6 O O O CD DO .� � 0 ° D ?�, Al v •. ' o A 0.(7 0 co w p co 3 cwn = ° co 0 m ° 0 0 c 0 m N' ° y m 0 3 o o 0 0 (�D O O w o O. ow m &, - m < o w y co m ° c J • • a II m > E a 0-1 2 a a, \ m ( \ 0 { < ) _ a) z @ \ \ / 2 f 2 9 / 4 ` ƒ / G m m 6 ® k ° o /CO ƒ / CD E) E ? \ » e — a \ ! o ƒ ? 0 ƒ ° 2 2. \ 7 ® \ ( o = J E E / 2 7 { \ - \ 7 \ 0 E J \ i —1 \ _ \ / / - / � / \ CD C CT) ° C 2 ƒ —1 > H 0 m \ / - a E / � \ Q a 7 -' ° § / ( ) § -, co / _ / a ) « O 0 _CAD` { k \ ) 0 \ 0 co g \ { 7 / ƒ ° / 7 !_ \ 2 - , ® Q o. / \ CO \ \ k E a § - > ; = E \ 0 £ ! § ) 7 \ \ E w CO » EI \ ƒ gg = -, E G - , e = 3 •» co ° « \ S § 0 = CD { cn \ § c E E OD - m » o » } § \ ` 0 R % f 3 k DO s 3 0 / i 5 2 § 3 \ k \ / 0 $ § m \ CD { \ p = 0 / o 7 0 y - 9 ) - / N) J } \ f ƒ / C \ 0 k \ a ` co > co 0 { a / y co ° 2 \ C ® \ _ § \ CD / o \ / G 2 \ / ff 53 - ( f } \ a :Ti \ � \ ` 7 ® CD a ,% o 0 2 \ \ \ 0 • 7) m c m m K m o n D p 0 0 0 S N °d — Cw'' a O 27 w N N ' m ° y w o' m mm p_ t, O C • E 3 C O Q a N co D 7 ' n 7 m 0 Co D w m(D •m c * 2 m w T 3 w m o N cD N N (D C r Wm O c't w co CD _ D N CD O N a D < N < N0 .N 0 , CD ) 3 w cD C a c w �, m n B C) ° ° D 3 7 0 0 = C w ` CD O T a CD° g ff , O N Q 0 m < 2 N c0 • _ mz TO (Z_ !)O O co ? D m O 'O O) p CD N O N n.-. a p � .•. . N CD 3 w w N � D. o AD 0 w w m 3 w Nm m ›, N 3 w CD p c c p c> 'w m p: C Q ° ▪ m — o m ro o A) Q c 1m o c n a c oo co c o j o 7 °n 3 n 3 0 — N m �` m o T o m m N a CD N p 0 N _0 m C3 ( -+ p)44, w m N m-m v a N 0 0 7 if) . O s N �� a m N cw w N w w m m m m _ a o a, 0 ° w ° c 3 a � • � 6 = m w N m m 0 u' N � �: m u o .o '3 c • N° N N O D � N 3 D C co cn w � .. _ �- fi 3 rg , CD 3 A 0 O. O N Z a w 5. 3. NC N 3 - c a (3 ° 0 T = a D cQ o o 0 m > 3 0' o w C 3 3 0 a w m m ° m 0 N C a n w < T D 6m N a• °O D w N w Er °(<;111) C D (o 'o Ao 012 -°o- w cCD CD 3 m CD m m Q 3 D 4 Q Nm s,A3 w 'fl w v w m , 3 m� m o g• o 0 o w w 2.o a C a 3 3 a) , . o N -y o 6 v m N N ' A C p% j N Q D = 7 Oo N ) N w C - - , 02, 3 ,c3 ^ O a W w O o 3 --. - F CD _ 0 O S w n N O N A O O N CD O D r. A O nT S N CD < n Q to a W Cn N cQ _ n w O ? O N O N N N O n C D 1) 0 . _ ° N < N p a) c Q N 3 ) f N Q6 w CD w w * a Q a) CO ° 5 0 n ? a x. = a) N D 6 N 7 0 _= C CDn °— _ U) ' n. N 3 '0 O 0 Q o a o a v w p co < ° ° _ O CD o Z '' : N a ) C 0 T 5_"` C 3 ¢'< N• O w O N w D ¢)co m 0 wm m ▪ 7 m , w w = c1m r • m _ a o 3 w Hill N w v 3 0 w ( m co O tD m m m m -0 o ja, -w < e 5- � U m w 5' 3� ° m m m m ° ° -I w Do CD Atk °n 2m Q `a m a S3 3 CD m CD n a ° C m o w o o v m mC ° 0 o ° w m . am - 0 a c 0 c w ° m N Y; a N CD 0 ° °m m m o 3 3 i a a a w n c v c c 3 C n o in 0 6 m C ', o N r a 3 0 CD 0 o c c n D � m° a .11 N Cr 0 N 3 00 S O = 0 0: w CD .0 p Ch O O a 7 < O � cuaw 2 ma�'f3 c c a m 0 0 ¢ 0 D m _CD SI) N m m 0 a < m- - o m m :: m a m m o m3 3 0 6 , ° m cNi w a s O C C CS .p CT a < N '"fin 3 `� m Q ° a CD o 0 o C < w 3 N w O fD s °' tD cn n j 3 0 a CD A CD o o N o a CD N < m CD CD o s cD — Iti z:: a �, a 3 ( S - CD O X CD CD 0 N CD (D C Cep .N. (D < 5 2 m N ca cc)N J .N. N r. O D W z m F. r Z Z c7 p 0 2 Do H Z m m O CD (/� D y 33 O DO M 2 a m �Z z o � m m c oN o m Cr) o 0 r_ ow CS Cr SD rn b CD co › co cn 3 Et 71 o --.1 o v D o C D D C m 0 l'0 o w 3 m m m � m fl m o m c c to C o T 7 m m r, w Lm m m ' 3 C o n 0 o co o h to z m m rn �v m .3 n _O w Q m m _< « 5 ° 0 0 O m n w w < a tp O w s * w � w W c w _ " lls 3 N w o °O °w `G = O o LO< o n a 5.a R n N N" u AS' N° w r m �a N y O a x "x N O ;Q o p = �, , m C v n c w a n' C O - ca O m m c 5+ a o m n _� 2 0 m 0 3 w c ,< c p w m o ` 1m o 0- n N h D m m m i f < C<n CD c O n cp VE 0 CD Fri m '4 a nm< N j --(1 > 4 <D O <D o .• •D to m ° u a m ro h m ' N H w - r F'`7 DU o 0 n ° `« r »up '5 cn a ID CD FD <w a J O a w c 1 n = N° o Cnm� Wog: 6' N N f m F u h « wi0 ti,0_ D D ° o m 3 O o a G n g Q n a m C-0 Q `K —n w o w ii n .m ET) N m N C a O O w a ¢T 5' w 3 o cn ' a e a cr ea t t AO a. o CD CD FO iir w w m wa t CD 0 o co o Q IP t , 3 co K n BELOW IS A COMBINED LIST OF BRYANT SLIMP'S AND CRAIG KOEHL'S COMMENTS FROM THE CITY COUNCIL/BSC WORKSHOP MEETING HELD ON OCTOBER 22, 2007 Sean - - - These are the basic notes of what I heard on Monday evening at the workshop session: The original goal of the Tree Ordinance was the preservation of trees - trees are considered first. What kind, how many, how to preserve were the issues. Damage to trees by developers and their crews / subs back in late 1980s /early 1990s was a real problem Heritage trees: The harder to remove them, the better. Tree types A desire is to use quality oaks used in replacements Permits Desire to not have BSC as the people who limit what happens on a homeowner's property/property rights. How to address replacement trees on crowded yard that die or are damaged. What happens if the owner does not want to replace these trees? Michael T. wants to make the ordinance where a big tree devalues a property when a developer is buying the land for a new house. See Ms. T's handout How do we give clear rights for private property, and not becoming intrusive of peoples rights to do what they want on their property? Trees planted on the public area are the best. A lot of issues raised were from the perspective of a resident owner wanting to change trees on their property. The preservation from the developer (who is a land owner) was overlooked. How can we make the ordinance work with no classes of ownership? Sean, Rather than creating another document, I thought I would just add my interpretations below Bryant's. As is the case when a group of people gathers and exchanges ideas, I assume that each of us heard the same things but may interpret them differently...anyway, this is what I jotted down: Comments from one Councilperson: 1. Trees should be one of the first things considered when planning a new house. And preservation of the larger trees should be priority. Penalty for Heritage trees should be fairly stiff. Removal of Heritage trees should go before BSC. Genus diversity is a good idea to prevent the Oak Wilt, and other, epidemics. • • Comments from another Councilperson: Only trees in right of way should be protected. Trees removed from the private property should not require replacement plantings. Replacement plantings required for protected trees should be limited. Try to get all large shade trees in City in the public right of way and front building setbacks. Provide incentive for removing "Low Value" trees. Protecting and requiring replacement of trees on Private property is encroaching on private property owner's rights. Comments from yet another Councilperson: Replacement of dead, dying, or diseased trees not very well received. Just my overall impression and opinion: A compromise may be to significantly lower replacement requirements for trees that are permitted for removal and located within the "buildable" area of a building site. Maintain the Heritage tree requirements and replacement requirements for any Class 1 or 2 tree that is permitted for removal that is located in the front right of way, front building set back area, or rear building setback area — provided the canopy exclusion is not met with trees to remain. Also, make it more difficult to remove trees in the ROW and set back areas. I think that if we reduce the replacement requirements for trees in the "buildable" area then we increase size of the replacement trees required...simply because we will have less room to plant trees, so the trees that are planted should be fairly substantial to re-establish the lost canopy area more quickly. We probably should not require replacement of the dead and dying trees. These are the issues I interpreted, what did you all hear? Thanks, Craig • PROPOSED TREE ORDINANCE CONCEPTS DIFFERENCES BETWEEN KEY PROVISIONS Key Provision Current Proposed • Protected trees During construction: 6-in.+ In street area: 2-in.+ Trees for which a permit is required for Otherwise--- On building site: 4-in.+ removal or damage ---in/near street area: 6-in.+ ---anywhere: 12-in.+ • Trees allowed to be removed --Diseased, damaged, dead --Diseased, damaged, dead Categories of trees which may be --Hazardous --Hazardous removed or damaged(but only if --Low-value(Class IV) --Class III-IV, if upgrading trees at a site authorized by permit) --Unreasonably impeding use of site --Suppressed by other trees --Interfering with existing structure --Interfering with proposed use of site • Heritage trees No special provision Permit to remove or damage requires Class I or 1I trees,24-in.+ approval of BSC • Replacement categories --Unreasonably impeding use of site --Diseased, damaged, dead Categories of trees which must be --Hazardous replaced, if removed or damaged --Class III-IV, if upgrading trees at a site --Suppressed by other trees --Interfering with existing structure --Unreasonably impeding proposed use of site Unless good canopy cover remains • Replacement calculation Inch-for-inch, by diameter, but--- Sq-inch-for-sq-inch, by basal areas, but-- Quantity of trees required to be planted ---reduced by tree evaluations ---reduced by tree evaluation to replace trees removed or damaged ---reduced if high-value trees(6-in.+) ---possibly reduced by cost factor (usually based on sizes measured as will remain ---zero if good canopy cover remains trunk diameter or trunk cross-section Exception: Stem-for-stem if hazardous, "basal"area") diseased, damaged, dead, suppressed or interfering with existing structure(or zero if good canopy cover remains). • Replacement location 1st. On the site or in adjacent street area 1st: On the site or in adjacent street area Where replacement trees must be 2nd: In reasonable proximity to site 2nd: In street area within 1,000 feet planted, listed in order of preference 3`d: Through tree trust(in reasonable 3rd: Street-side yards within 1,000 feet proximity to site,within City limits) 4th: Through tree trust(prefer City fund) • Replacement size, species ---2-in, sometimes 4-in. ---4-in. usually,2-in. sometimes Minimum size and species of replacement ---Class I or II (usually) ---Class I or II trees • Permit types Two--- One---"tree permit" Basic types of permits that can ---building permit with"tree authorize tree removal or damage disposition"conditions ---"tree permit" • Tree evaluations 10 categories,40 possible points 4 categories, 100 possible points How trees are evaluated(the score is (Refocused on class,condition,future used in the calculation for replacement potential and location) trees) • Minimum planting standard ---2 to 7 trees(depending on site size) ---One per 1,800 sq.ft. of site area Minimum tree requirement for each site ---Size 2-in.+ ---Size 4-in.+ (triggered by major development) ---Class I or II (unless pre-existing) ---Class I or II Unless good canopy cover remains • Diversification of the Urban Forest Not addressed Requires diversification by genus • Planting trees in street areas Allowed Strongly emphasized and in some cases required • • TREE PRESERVATION AND PROTECTION REGULATIONS The Building and Standards Commission has been meeting since February 2007 concerning the provisions of Chapter 82 of the Code of Ordinances entitled"Urban Forest and Enhancement". Staff approached the BSC to consider revising the provisions in order to: correct and simplify the regulations. One of City Council's long-term goals has been to review and revise the permitting process, including the evaluation of development sites for compliance with tree preservation and protection requirements, removal of trees and replacement plantings. The BSC had some input from the general public through meetings earlier in the year. Citizen concerns over the loss of large or"heritage"trees, relative size of replacement plantings and their locations, and the inflexibilities in permitting a property owner to remove trees prompted the BSC to explore new avenues and options that are in some instances, very different from the current regulations. Attached is a chart highlighting the major differences between the current provisions and the proposed changes. The subsequent attachments are proposed changes to the existing ordinance. The pages are not in ordinance format, and were assembled to give City Council an opportunity to understand the basic direction that the BSC is headed toward and to get comments and feedback before proceeding with the ordinance format. • = o DJ O ° O C N m o ° O 7 m i O .r -,-.. 0 w w ° a o 5 m 0 c 7 c 7 ° O C G m D m r Z co O 7 r - c 3 00 H O N A D m °- O D CD o m S 0 3 C 7 0 A) m Cr) H D ikr W O v r 3 > m r o v o co o c 0 H a w m 0 cQ c cn c o m m 0 0 A co ry 7 3 - 2 m m q a a m 3 Z H _ C) 0 0 0 <0 4. y ° C A) 7 m f) N N (/ (n ( V D N 0 37 ,,,A) <m w _ _ _ = O o F 0 O a_ = = _ co c 3 0 0 0 O .C. Q 6 m `° : C n 0 — < < < < m Q -n 0 in r o 3 0 0 7 0 o = m C C Z z W w o S. 3 0. 0 S. 3 s. m c. 3 N o m CO C _ < 3 _ 7 D 0 w m 0, = Q 3 o, a 9 a A- Z sv C 3 m T 0 w D 0 0 7 Z 37 0 37 0Z 3J W m ITt m >J c? v 37 co 3] 33 37 cD W 31 - m ' o. —�i -o - ° ca' O CD m cD m ° m (D c ° O. N m o = 0 7- E .O w _a a _0 w _0 a _. w w O m C o C w C a) - w a 0 `< • O Q m _ m p_ co a Si a o a 0 J co 0 FD- 0 m 3 7 Z 7 3 co 7 3 1 7 < O 0 0 U] H 7 7 v W CD j H"� o w CO (D 3 3 m C =,< -< m m w A C) o m H � v z ° a 3 co - CD o m m co m o 0 co.° c •> 3 (� co D N m 7 a in C0 c, r• m n Zs CI D 3 I3 D > D c p c 0 m a Q rn 3 O- 3 ww m cn a O_ "O - TI CD •3•. Q D 7 r fD C)fr, O w 7' o< 6 0 co 7' (D a (D a N 0 co O w tQ Ai H N < D co 0 (D c w (D (p 7. 3 5 (p w O 0 w 7 o .< 0 'CO w Z '' a 7' N 3 co K N (D ° O_ (D (D c/) .-. a O * _ a' v 07 - 3 S O cD — m -°- cn _ o (wD 5- $ 0 s ° N Co o 0_ n 0 o- o 3' 3 w 9, 0 7 N *, {n co 0 0 a0 Z O 0 , D w o m ° o ° w 3 ° m = n 0 o o Zv o _. w c D �*. 6 o a CD a m O 0 w Awl 7' *. N" CD w 0- Q 0 0 O o (On D O c O a' 0' N 0. v F) o o (0 0. x. 7 a) a co _ cn o 7- a 0 m _ N O N w O ° O CO 7 0_ 51) 0 w •w„ (° A7 7. 6 O ? lD N '-. ° o -1 C N Q ° ° _ (o w m a c ° ra, o CD CD 0 r FE, m c (n 0 a 0 (0 co w 0 3 m - 3 w w a N o o o c c 0 o (5. o * w m N_ w 3 C = - c N n o N ro 7 N 0 0 C 8 7 v> m 7 W 7 O 3 N 3 a o c o C Al 7 '(3 7 8 'c 8 O ° _ 0 7 m c - w w °' O W O < m N w w 0 0 (] X - 0 °w _� CO 7a Z n < D c m 3 c a °- 3 ° a w ° m W D o a w co 0 0• S 3 CD m N - CD c C o_ 0 (wD 7 0" N o 0 m m C fl m n w ° s * c8 co 0 7 N CD v7-i' W D - 2) 07 O N O 00 N v .� vw s w a N_ 3 3 wn a y m m CD 3 _ m _ CD CD O Q o 6 w (D w 5 a , 0 .-. 0 --1 7 w m 0 cD m __ 7 < o m c `o m m a �' C N O 7 a (!i (D 7 -1 CO O (/�' w 6 0 0 0 7 N w o 1 - c. Q 7 m w o 3 C 7 (0 0 0 7 0 0 m CO CO o CD O Alt - - (D w K W O. w 3 3 a 3 0 l o w O0 ro ^ D 0 0 Z SU Q 0 O D 0 (f0 w m 3 3 w m 0 2 o a - o ro on a m m JD CD 0 o o co -00 w o "°6 (D m o DJ ) co co o - -0 z -1 o W 0 N n 0 CD a D 0 co 3 �< 7 N 3 CD U) �• O a < CD .-. 5 m co D 0 O c0D = cn �° (Dm 7 C < s c n' C7 0 0o D° w fQ 0 5 co D D D D p0 ° B . N -1 D 0 0 - 0 3 `<< o O m ° 0 3 = �' Cr, w O 9 - 3 m 3 m w w co C z. 0 7 -0 CD (D (D- a c (D cD co m O S. a O m CD 3 CD cn o w 0 a m 0 3 3 0 = c w Q o *. 3 °_ m ° _ 0 n 0 5' . co ° CD CD 0 a w w c° 03 ui m .P 0 w =, m 0 _ _ CA w 3 -OO a 7 = _ N o O w - CD Co -0•< - - (D N 7 0 o c O O -°0 0 5 Cw<D a a N , Cl) < G CD -a D 0 o o -°O 0 o w co° 3 ° 3 a i 11 'a 3 3 N c co as o m m-o S CD c3D O (DD U co "D a 3 w = a' 3 0 .0 .o CD 1] CD a a '< -O c c CD �<-,. w w 3 0 m m 0 O 5. m CD a < C - `wo ° a a 3 CD a -Oa _.'Q -0 m 0 O of w c 7 c m 31 7J cwi N0 m a o 3 °a m 3- 70� 3 � O cD. 3 a DC _. w 'G o 0 - CD w c• O 3 O 3 a o a co ° O N - - ° 0 N t 0 0 3 3 a 0 0 -, 0 3 o O w , w c O O a 7 D c° a a - ? 3 a 3w o O a >7 c w S. D 3 w ° N o o' 3a 5 m ° CD c N < w m o =. 3 CDC) m w to c n co c -' N 0 (D - o 03 a o_ c,.G n a OM °' w 0 '�' 7 O (Wp (D a (OD Cp N co aaa ` n a 7- � ° `mom � � � o--° co •=t � 7w 0 - m 13 mc- av, a 0 3 3 w 0 Q 3 3 °O O 6 o N 7 0 (D 0' 0 -0 0 Cn 3 3 D o = n O N = c5 3 m c a I 3 m o 0 o co f o w_ ° w a G y o 0 ai O O a 5 O o m O o - < w o 3 n cQ O - n 3 a 3 m c o' 5 co m 3 0' * a (3) ^2 0 3 m a w 0 Cl) w °' w �- O w 0 N _ 3 Om a 3 'O co 0 co CD CD 0 7 N c 0 w 0 G (D O 12L. 0 o w w * 0 3 CD 0 w 3 - O 0 O O 3 0 ° o v_ w ° a m o a _ 3 a CS -O CD 3 Cl) N ° a a N m °O (D 1] * S fo w R. 3 G a w c 5 o O O O m e o 6 3 3 o a O c m co A N ( n o = 3 (o p 7 0 o a 6 C 3 a 3 = 7 (D Q CD co 0 cD (D CS ? cD O �< '0-. m_ m co < N w � 7 ? N 3 d Qi: C3D N cA N CD fD c° °-., 3 3 o 7 ° -Om 0 0-- O N -0 CD 0 N 3 (3D L 3 O C 7 C. °0 CD co• 0 o O o' 0 O o O c 0 CD 7 tv N _ a w a 3 < < c0 70 .0-. 0- c 0 o' * o a s m 3 m 3 n o O c A ° a ° CD N 3 5 3 O (° ... 3aa Owo w °a 3 � O o y m a 3 m 3 7 a m �. c a 3 1 w o -°o m .n m cn CD= °- co _3 = m (o c a o 3 .. a 0 3] 3 rn a 5 w o_ o m O o o CD g co D- a 3 O - 3 6 3 Co C w 6 3 co a a3 w CD w o co 0 3 0 -O co 3 w o CD 3 a 0 -0 � 3 w 0 0 CD 3 3 Co (D a `2 0 _. (D c) O = (n O Cl) o w - o in 3 Cr 0 3 O 0 1:0 cD 3 am w CD CD w o ca./-1-)) C. E. CD w _ A` < 7 0 O w ° 0 a On 0. •3 a u9i ci O 0- 0- m a cD D • r o Z Z D (n C M C v O O m >- 1 I I 71 (1) m C) -1 o to Z -1 > n 000 -1 nn -1 _ w w w w 1 o D o - 77 w °Eij N o ° —a °' - m 0- m <n N 0 o m _ x `°° N co' N N N- m o ' - -a c ~ w C _ r c a> U)5 a E. n - w ° c o ° _ c , ° C 0- N - D N 3 o o o St D (D N(n (Q p) N 7' w /)p 0 o N N w o 5.co O n ) a w w w m ° -. N 5 o ° o = a -o Q Z w o c m D -' CD 10( a m 0- Cr) ° < 33 o ° `< m N o ° I) C.N _ o g 0 ° oN °' . 3 Co 1 3 0 3 D (') 0 °= , ° w - o 2_ 0_ m e Q (D . E.. w v Q U) 0 0 C K o a n o N E CD 0 n a m o m m w m . 2 0,_ o <° a o 3 ° co a ° o a rr Q cn N 3 a N a y 3 m a w 3 s ° c o c 0 ° o o 5 •- w N ° o w o w o 0 3 o = m u co m a D, N ° ° con °- 5' ° g 6 o m v N a ° a ° a w o w (CD o - 2. � N < D N Cr a CD (D �. Oa < Q. C - 7 CD C7 3 <' N 0 o CD 0 o n . Cr_ w = < *. Q' a 5 N 3 w o a 0 CD o �. N w w N O 5• ° ° O a CO a N N (c <. .' N <, a a a 7 D v ? p N 0 w = N N o ET; 5' Cn ¢�' a W 5.• N j- < D 0 O 0 ,C cD 0 Q- °' 3 N C S (D 3 a n w p m 0 c o m ww m o m m m ° c 53 0(n a -I om 0m 3 0 m w w m 5'w v o c - o ci Co S = N �- N N c. (/) 3 Q 5 * m a o 7 N 5. - •. cD 3 7 Q 2 (D CD )u 5 3 0 !... o o co c- w C a m '< w a w a c 0 'n a a CD ° -° w CD o D 3 c° - w o o N s w 5. CD -° cD ,m - - < w A(w o 3 wn c n 5. m O m+Q w o CD m cD a Q o(D o -0 D 3 o Cl) m o v N N D O N D o N N a N CD N 3 - o co w p ' -0 0 o ` n' q R5 ( 0. v, 7 N m o m m m w a o m o CD a a m a o N N fl- w 0 3 o N O m Q ` m w 0- ° m m D a, a, 0 w 0 a m < a' S ° w w a m ° - o N o aQ ty a a w m . c ° Q w sa, 0 m N °) 0 5 w 3 o w °' c° cQ 3 C o o `< o' n 7 Q S gj(D o 0 w \ N (N C 6°, w CD w N N Q Q N Q (n 0 -, w .n. cD N (D 2 w 7 E. D w M = o 42 m n w ; n o n o' 3 o n C con m v w w ° N o o N w m 0 0 (n 2 n N (n C o S m 0 0 ca CD s 2 - .g.- m ( ° a CD '< CD o � m ° w o < o cs < 2 * m o w w 13 C a ' N. (D N o N Cr CD C_ O 6 (D C .. a .-. — (D C Q 5 D a m 0 E 5' ° w m (5'w o CA 0 7 o 3 (C co "' (D Co 3 ^' N o o co SU..: o (D a o o �° w t�D' o a sty s* 3 a' 0 a a Q < .« 3 m ) a N o° n ° ° a_ Q w ° a) n = c c° ° (o o CD i Q m o 0 o c0 co 3 ° C° v N CT. t o co n < w N c m a = o o s m ( Q m c ? to o m o Cn o Q'° o NcD O * m a ° o N 4' ° ° CD � r Q CD° m (o a c c c tn m = CD Cl). c 3 to- Cn m * co 6 C- 3 _Q 7 a o m SU< N p) C c) o < `C3 N a N< 3 o o 3 w 3 w Q 3 c pi w o w a o v 5 5 co 5 < N 3 c N w o m w a a ("13 v o CO :n+ Q co ° N 1. N �s; tom . 79(3 ii iR Do z tn cn m m m y• c- c p p (m Q cn (D m. _TI 2 In O Q p 0° N 0 n° 1 D N N �N a 0 01 0 o o cn 0-m O 31 0 m x m o Q? W D m Z w -i N o cm ° m m 0 - p v in 0-CD‹ m m s o n Q D y n . ° r c0 a O C W m o w .• j m O = v Q 0 -0 5 i a --I �; w c 0cn ? v m o Q w o FD" j - C r m c m w m o D m O o o N m Q o a m m w 7 Q 3 m m w m w m w Q o 4' ° w m n O m C m 3 m O m — jj o -I ES . � O 7 ' 7 Q w m 7 ru su to 0 w m m 0 7 y � - D 3 m N 0`° _a C N co — w m a w ? w X (D o c Q 3 � a m m 6 m.-. o w vN ° @ m w 7 w N N o _� N• 0' R o - ff y D O n -n co n ca 7 m o 4 a 0 (J 'T m o O 0 N w m m w ° m o (O 0 Q o � m o a m .- N m o O a)D Cl) w m N m m 3 _ o- 3 o m " N O D g a O a o m m m m w cD _ w o c m N N 0 � m �°m Q cn � Q 7 O CD m y s m o 3 3 w _ ° w * (Q m o y � N 7' N (i cn mm C o w ''''' a. coca — Q a 3 m n< � m fm ft o m O U) - N w n . p ,_,, 0 O Da CD m m ° O N m ' O O O m D O m m N O m w m 0 .. D y N O =CD 0 o w O Q v N 0 m w 0 O D � �m E 4 " a m C �' o D Q D p c Q D C C u 3cvi w a o w O n N N S O CD(Q n w m D v o m m Q w 3 O p O w O O w' n m N D O m o m m D D D =_, O o 3 C m 5 m n co w o o o C C 5 o D C u _ Q ti m 3 x O 6 D y m -C:3 c m N 7 6 7 - 5 7 a T i m v » 0 D 7,. co m o c B m ° m 0 j .. O (D D cn 0 a (p O " "O o N 0 0 m CA D p .n o O ,O fD , Q (n "o „ Q O O w , o 3 f .(D o o Q C!f, D Q (D p m fl Xw Al .G 0 Q 0 w m w a =a m = — w O� O A O w O N raCb'H O( Q Q ? w s3 at o C C n m m Q s o o O O N . QO p m ' m _ (' N > ° w O ...1 CD �D O N (O m O w (D n Cl) w O C `� 6 O m 6 O 3 0 w S o a o .� e a O. -a3 a m o w m 7 fl at 5 O m N � 4 Q ° 7 O X w Q N m m 3 _ o IT 0. D c m S 3 C 00 o CD• o CD o (o n 7;1 if) D c 'O C C (° m c� m o U m 0. 0 6 m m 7 N O (O w m D b 3 � O w(n cD O w Si (p o m Q a 1 s • p O : ( m o w ^ O 3 O O C O w 0 O N 0 30 • © cD ._.D o .s m o o i OW a 6, o ° O 7 m — 6 a O C N m '?1'.5 D (D Q Flg cs ma)ow CD tsn A Q N D cs cD w Q = tD 3 co. j m O O O Ci N O y N (p 7 a (D` m O O CD =,, 07 b y N Gw D O -sAl O c Q • ® (D D O N 0 'a>Q y'N N �D (O rt t6O W 0 rtN 0 li • 2� � •z z O O n _ D .'.. o T ui o 3 o w Z *m 7J o o 5 co = Q c O m p a � c 7 C N a °CD_ n N a' m n a o a * 9 a w a m m N a Q p m CD N m N mn CD u pCD o N . m w -OW Es)-' 0 '-'71 '-'.171 H D C m a D C C<<<j n FtD w D m D D _ O. ° w D CD FD- - p n w >p fp N 0- m . 0 N 6 7 . m 'p j m w w m o S CD 3 O m m co Cu o n p (D m x o n w w .3 p.. 7..1 ' _ � NC w (D CD C ° D O B ryN 7' O (/)(D N N -` CD -s m m w CD m m O m CD o o m 3 co m n _CD cn SA w o 0 D O (Q w C p c D n 3 j. N m w 3 CD o Q m m 'c° ' 3 o m n . n D 2. Ill a N w C w m 2 0 ° p D m N O c o ° < < *, < r. w O N a m m wN X w w O-'O N C o 7 O. N 0) 0 0n 7 (fl< _� � w canm < D - N' w o O w 0 N w •" w E. w o5CD O D N 0' O c ,. U 0 O .O ' 0 N a ` S1 T- O j 2 0 -. ° .• a c° 5' c 0 _uj N m s w o w n m r° : o t m pw tN CD w a c C O O O S O O� Y A N „ ° N a a c y o o � °- w � O- 0 1- co C r) w w N N' N °- _ n O a N a N j '<< 3 " 3 7 6 p O w r p - 3 O n NO ~ O j 'D .O a cD d c CD O ,.O c CN . U < w, < O O D n d N 5 (D O , D o Q N p m 0 w mv D w ;,..„;:u :,..._:c c y O m m ?7 a °" 3N w 6 w D . 9 w -o m 3 m O a a O c a-o Q C am ° D a N o w m c 0 3 Q _ m n ' N N m w c w n w m m cf) is CD al a 3a a °j<. N 0D 7 Cp .4,..°_ A D_ c m — C as m v,'w o ° o ° .L co .N. -' 2 2 )� C Cp cn O (D 0 CD n () � 0 O 0 a '0 -n C <D D N p N K Q n N w: 3 O S CD 'Zr C N ° D 3 °- 7 Q a p a N -C O O ( CD W ° D w m O 3 D CD N O co CD CN "p N " D O 5 7 o- Cp O N tp • w C co..� ..S O N <I h _, ° a: c - O �-CD N 3 O 7 G .» w w *.'a :it G• C D (D C N D i O m < O N y 7 tp p Q p CD ow -8 -7 W . 2 :5 .N D n O N CD IO O C 3 D 5 w (� ` C O O � 7 C *^ Si) ,.' D n N CD : D r 7 n n N ?N w l (D Cn N ,m W m m V w m < to w o a c- v n m D O w n 0 m _ Q a 0 < m n m N tp °N ADo qr P a m 0 m m A, D g' `vD s a 7 N v n N N D m N@ O 0 w _ ° ° J..": w 3 (l w o ° n w w N , N m 3 a a o m n :y n m m cn n„ - 5 O n m N 0m N.) w m m° D - 7 N° 3 C w a m 0 D o n N (O O N N O p CD O l7 N O N p.+ "Ci D CD O o D ▪ m °- a< c c° • ° ° � m N po ° ° • w • N co-' m 0 co. CND O o ` m w x N D 5 n N N n • m 3 ° � 0 0 c .- o §, c IJ v, w o 3 ' 0 m Q c 2 N„a 8o 0 0 ca N al CD N N m rs D.. co Q N ca,), D (D O N r* g C 5 * N CD 0 CD Ti n E. O w ._ 1:0; ;.. • ir G D< > C_ <O M W n -1 z Z E n =i r 01 zz m 11 -< m c• D D DO n z Q m 0z o z o- -1 N m w 0 O N r O •• 0 m m a • C) iii 7J c c w co a cn - m 0 m m c n 53 O `o - 0 m 3 3 C m c a m P7) m m 2 cn 3 .- c O up (D W N a7 O z o co c • 0 = c CD • o n -• w 3 c- m s a> c° o N 0 S) (D c w n Co FLT m c a m-• N a _= 0 m co a '-5 °3 0 n 3 ° o . vi o, En o 3 w a 5' m 0- o' m 5 a 0 C c t°"-Ri' a c E. Q co C (D cD 3 w c p? o CD CD -n °- q. _. X a w 0 N <. 0 0 0 0 co 3 < N fff,..-0 cD A S A7 3 O O 0 6 5.-6) < W CO 0 C O 0 O 6 c #J! 0 D Q O. cD = ... 3 (D O c ° m .., cD a a c co 5 Al 5 CD 5 a s a m ° cn m:8 a9 no m a o _ b# Q a CD �' .r`G O CD can O N Z 0. c CO N a o Al N.,,. N 0 0 st Al 7 C) N _, N O 0 O 0 a g' 3 2 CO CD 0 >' 3 �:. ', N O O 3 U N S cp '0 5 C- Q -p (1) A> CD C. .. m cD N g N IID - d :!. :, CD N w ° 5` a�' c° m a CD a a 0 <n 0 LCD W 3 C 0 a a 5. iv A m 0 to w